Understanding replacement cost and ACV claims
Understanding your claim: replacement cost vs. actual-cash value
Insurance has a lingo all its own, and sometimes things that sound similar can mean very different things. When it comes to settling your homeowners, condo-unit owners, and renters insurance claim, knowing the difference between replacement cost and actual-cash value (ACV) – and how they work together – can help you feel confident about your coverage and what to expect.
How insurance companies settle property claims
Insurance companies have two options for settling property claims:
Replacement cost. That means the amount needed to repair, rebuild, or replace your damaged home using materials of similar kind and quality at today’s prices. Replacement cost also applies to damaged or destroyed personal property. It doesn’t factor in depreciation.
ACV. It looks at an item’s replacement cost, but subtracts depreciation for age, wear and tear, and obsolescence. In other words, it reflects what an item is worth the moment before it was destroyed.
Before either method is used in settling a claim, the insurance company will apply the deductible you selected when you bought your policy, and the settlement will stay within your policy’s terms and limits.
Some insurance policies settle claims using ACV-only coverage on certain categories of property or on all categories.
Other policies offer replacement-cost coverage where, depending on the size of the claim, they use a combination of replacement cost and ACV coverage in settling claims.
How does replacement-cost coverage work?
Under a certain damage threshold, many companies, including PEMCO, will simply settle your claim for replacement-cost coverage (what it would cost to buy a new item of similar kind and quality), provided that’s the type of policy you selected.
But let’s say you have a larger claim, perhaps a water leak that caused enough damage to exceed that threshold. Those claims are typically settled through a combination of ACV and replacement-cost coverage.
How replacement cost and ACV coverage often work together
On larger claims, replacement-cost coverage for personal belongings often initially involves ACV. Once your deductible for the claim is met, an insurance company may pay you upfront for the depreciated value of an item. And, if it’s something you do decide to replace, they’ll make a second payment to you, reimbursing you for the total cost based on your sales receipt.
In the water leak example, let’s say one of the many damaged items was an older china cabinet that would cost $1,500 to buy today. Maybe you want to replace it. But also possible, you may no longer need a china cabinet and don’t really want another one.
To give you cash-in-hand upfront, your insurer would pay you the china cabinet’s ACV (depreciated) value of, let’s say, $900. That money is yours to keep and use for whatever you want, even if it’s not another china cabinet or anything related to the water damage. If you do decide to replace it, they’d make a second payment, reimbursing you for the additional replacement cost based on your sales receipt for the new china cabinet.
(If you’re wondering how coverage works for auto claims, check out this example for a stolen car.)
We can help you understand your coverage
When it comes to understanding your policy and coverage, you never have to go it alone. If you have questions, don’t wait until renewal to talk with your local PEMCO agent or a representative at 1-800-GO-PEMCO. We mean it when we say PEMCO is “the insurance you get,” and we’re happy to offer free policy reviews [link to policy review story when posted] anytime.
*Terms defined here are for general educational purposes only. They do not replace or change your policy contract. If you have questions about your coverage, please refer to your policy’s language and talk with your PEMCO agent or a PEMCO representative.
Share on social media